Originally Posted by
Kitdy
I have driven only one VW car so your view is more illuminating, but no less, I think that pretty much all the German Big Luxury 3 have are "beautifully built and have excellent paint work." Ferrer has taught me of the dead steering feel of udis- maybe indicative of luxury cars but I'd wager Bimmers are better to drive (it seems you agree) and if you want mad luxury you go to Benz - Audi I see as somewhat in the middle and not really as good as either of the other two.
As for the A8 leading the class in your view, I think that's surprising to hear as the engine seems maybe a bit small/lacking in torque in comparison to the fire breathers AMG and BMW have to offer but I could be wrong I also just think of the other two offerings as better for some reason. I'd have pegged the S-Class 1, 7 Series 2, and the A8 bringing up the rear, although this is speculation.
What was it about the A8/S8 that you valued so highly and why would you put it as class leader?
I am not sure you have to drive SEATs or Skodas as they are just badge engineered VWs with different interiors and potentially other things (I am not too knowledgeable on these two).
I think the interior quality on MB has been terrible lately, on the other end I have not been impressed with BMW's paint work, I think Audi does both of them brilliantly. The A3 and A8 are fun to drive, the A4 (I haven't driven the current one, just the previous) and the A6 are a little boring to drive, but are very pleasant and luxurious. Keep in mind: NOTHNG beats a 3 Series.
The advantage the A8 has is that it's lighter than the S or 7 which negates the need for the massive torque and makes the car a better handler. And if you really need that torque the A8 W12 is priced much less than the S600 or 760iL for what I consider to be a better car. I also think the Audi is the best looking.
"The Metric System is the tool of the Devil! My car gets 40 Rods to the Hogshead and that's the ways I likes it!" -Grandpa Simpson