Aston Martin V8 Vantage vs BMW Z4M Coupe vs Porsche Cayman S

[Monty_Burns]

Hope this aint a repost. Anyways they're all proper sports cars and I love them all. What would u buy?

[BMW325]

IMO these are the 3 coolest 2-seaters on the market today, nice comparo

Id take the Aston...but if Im paying for one, Id buy the BMW

[shadesMC]

def. the vantage. all of the cars are good, but the aston is just such a better looking car, and it outguns the others. actually just the cayman...i don't really know anything about the Z4M

[NuclearCrap]

I'd take a Cayman S. It has better fuel economy than most sports car, and you get the most out of what you pay because it's a Porsche. A fully loaded Cayman S is $67k at my local dealer, geat price for such a great car.

[shadesMC]

yeah i forgot to say i love the cayman s too...i flipped out when i first saw it. but i kind of fell in love with the aston too. throw in a poll!

[bmwpower]

I'd take the Z4 M based on two reasons, everyone knows porsche held back the Cayman S and it has much greater potential and i couldn't buy the car knowing that, Also the aston would cost so much more to run and insure and i don't believe it is that good looking..

[PerfAdv]

Cayman S for all that make it great Porsche. And with the saving over the AM, I'd have Techart tone down the lurching treefrog factor...

[silverhawk]

ive seen the Cayman S, Vantage & the Z4 coupe concept car recently & the Cayman S is the best looking of the 3. i thought that it would be an ugly Carrera but its a very nice car & i sat in it. the other 2 didnt interest me that much.

[Tuscan666]

Aston Martin. Everyone seems to have a Porsche or a Beemer these days. (Can't beat the sound track it makes either)

[Cyco]

The Z4M isnt the prettiest BMw ever built, the Cayman will always be looked at at the car for the person who cant afford a 911 and that leaves only 1 choice

[2ndclasscitizen]

The Z4M isnt the prettiest BMw ever built, the Cayman will always be looked at at the car for the person who cant afford a 911 and that leaves only 1 choice

well, we all know what you were gonna pick

[Clivey]

Ummm, the Vantage is MUCH more expensive than the other two...

...an unfair comparison but even so I'd take it BECAUSE it's worth more, I could sell it to someone who wants to bypass the waiting list and buy something I actually wanted.

[quattro_20v]

Just do me the BMW, I like the looks of it. And today everyone wants an aston martin wich just sounds loud but not any special to me, I can name a lot of cars that sound better. And the porsche just looks bad imo.

And for those who want to know the Z4M coupe has the 343 hp 3.2L inline 6 from the 'old' M3

[jorismo]

Hard one... The Aston has the best looks, the Cayman best value for price I recon. I'd go with the Porsche: good looks, nice performance and quite affordable.

[6'bore]

These can't be compared...not in the same price bracket.