[Voting] Comp 37 Weekly Automotive Photo Contest

[Cotterik]

rockefella u cant miss out SPH's photo that makes it an unfair contest

[SPHFerrari]

yea its been almost 24 hours, most of the voting has been done. i find it a bit unfair.

[Speedracer38]

I agree. If you were chosen to run the comps you cant leave out peoples pictures. SPH had a great pic and a good chance of winning. Very unfair...

[Cotterik]

post the pic SPH i havent seen it

[SPHFerrari]

http://www.ultimatecarpage.com/forum...8&postcount=25

[Rockefella]

I'm deeply sorry SPH. I completely left out your image/entry but still have you listed in the polls . I think it may have to do with the cut+paste job that I did with the entries, might have resulted in accidental deletion of your pic. If you want you can re-submit that picture next week. I don't know what happened this voting, first I left out the second half of the pictures for like 10 minutes, left out your pic SPH, decided Matra's pic wasn't worthy, etc.

[Rockefella]

I agree. If you were chosen to run the comps you cant leave out peoples pictures. SPH had a great pic and a good chance of winning. Very unfair...

I did not purposely leave out SPH's pic, it was just a personal error, I hope he understands. I've already hosted about 18 weeks of competitions (GT4, a week or two of Chop Comp, and this) so it's not as if I don't know what I am doing.

[Rockefella]

NEVERMIND all the text upstairs of this post, I think I have a solution to this entire ordeal. After the winner of this competition is decided, I'll have a runoff, between your pic and the overall victor of this week's voting. If you come out with the win in the runoff, then I'll add a win-tally to both your score and the winner of this voting. However, if you lose, then the competition will go on as normal. Sound fair?

[CHEESE-TACULAR]

wtf where is my pic

they knew you would win and particularly steal my one vote, so, you were left out

[Cotterik]

NEVERMIND all the text upstairs of this post, I think I have a solution to this entire ordeal. After the winner of this competition is decided, I'll have a runoff, between your pic and the overall victor of this week's voting. If you come out with the win in the runoff, then I'll add a win-tally to both your score and the winner of this voting. However, if you lose, then the competition will go on as normal. Sound fair?

sounds almost fair, but the voter still doesnt see SPH's photo compared to the other photos that may not have won the original competition, but the voter may not like SPH's as much as one of the other photos, which then means that the run-off is still not 100% fair.

[Rockefella]

sounds almost fair, but the voter still doesnt see SPH's photo compared to the other photos that may not have won the original competition, but the voter may not like SPH's as much as one of the other photos, which then means that the run-off is still not 100% fair.

But that's the best I can do. Unless, everyone agrees to me making a second voting thread, with all of the original competitors. You guys offer up some ideas.

[Cotterik]

nah thatd interupt the competition schedule. I guess the only good solution is the run-off, albeit an un-natural way of deciding. Maybe SPH could enter the photo into next weeks competition instead? I say let SPH decide

[Rockefella]

nah thatd interupt the competition schedule. I guess the only good solution is the run-off, albeit an un-natural way of deciding. Maybe SPH could enter the photo into next weeks competition instead? I say let SPH decide

Sure thing, I already stated he could re-enter that picture. BTW, I could make the voting into a form with no interference by starting week 38 immediately after this poll closes. Then, when voting is finalized, I'll post the winner in the new thread.

[Cotterik]

now all we need is SPH's decision.

[Egg Nog]

I've changed my vote from McReis to Rebirth of Xar, since I voted before I saw the second set. It will still say my name under McReis, but the numbers have changed.