Photography-Edit Fortnightly Competition #01

[Pinin]

I don't know if you'll allow this, tell me if not.

Pinin
Audi S6 Avant
Bottom of my street
Taken around November
Canon PowerShot A85
Photoshop 7
Modifications:

Black & White
Crop
Contrast
Borders

[johnnynumfiv]

Johnnynumfiv
Mitsubishi Evo
Autocross
Canon S2 IS
Photoshop Elements
Mods:
Crop
Hue/Saturation

[Esperante]

Would this bit be legal?

Esperante
Maserati Coupe
Chicago, IL
June, 2005
Hue/Saturation
Liquify filter

[Niko_Fx]

Niko_Fx
Ferrari 360
South Beach / Miami (Last weekend)
Kodak Z740
Saturation of most colors / Frame.

[spi-ti-tout]

I'm sorry, Niko and Pinin, yours are not allowed. You can make it either whole b&w or Sepia, otherwise it'll just become another chopping comp. Esperante, yours is fine.

[2ndclasscitizen]

its hardly chopping, Canon cameras let you do that when you take the shot

[drakkie]

Drakkie
Opel Manta
"Het Hok"
november 2nd 16:44
Olympus D-540z
Photoshop9.0 CS2
Modifications:
-desaturate
-curves
-hue/saturation



.psd file on request only(you can still see the mods in it.)

[spi-ti-tout]

its hardly chopping, Canon cameras let you do that when you take the shot

Oh, do they? In that case, it would be allowed.

[Niko_Fx]

Saturation of most colors / Frame.

-> Colour/Hue/Saturation Adjustment

I'm sorry, Niko and Pinin, yours are not allowed. You can make it either whole b&w or Sepia, otherwise it'll just become another chopping comp. Esperante, yours is fine.

[Esperante]

I'm sorry, Niko and Pinin, yours are not allowed. You can make it either whole b&w or Sepia, otherwise it'll just become another chopping comp. Esperante, yours is fine.

Yeah, mate, sorry, but I don't get that. I removed colour in parts of my photo just like Niko did.
I don't think this will turn into another chop comp if the modifications are limited to filters and contras/saturation/hue/brightness.

[spi-ti-tout]

Yeah, mate, sorry, but I don't get that. I removed colour in parts of my photo just like Niko did.
I don't think this will turn into another chop comp if the modifications are limited to filters and contras/saturation/hue/brightness.

This competition was started because many were complaining that in the Photography competition a lot of it was upto camera advantage with inbuilt features and such. So this one was started to give an equal advantage to all (for example, maybe even a photo from a phone cam can win if filtered right) and it seems like a good idea. I said Niko's and Pinin's was not allowed because the whole photo was b&w except for the subject, which I was not sure was a feature on cameras. However, 2CC has already mentioned that it is, so they are eligible to qualify.

[Niko_Fx]

Mine wasn't a camera feature, so I guess I'm out.

[spi-ti-tout]

You're not.

I'll say it again.
Some cameras can adjust hue/saturation/colour/brightness and have red/blue/green/boogly/black/sepia etc filters and some don't. This competition was started to give an advantage to all, especially if you can't do any of those features. 2CC said that feature CAN BE DONE on a Canon camera, which means it's a disadvantage to who can't do it, which means that even if you do it digitally on PhotoShop or any other program you still QUALIFY TO BE IN THE COMP.

[Pinin]

Mine was done in photoshop so I guess I'm out too. I'd allow this, but it's not up to me.

[spi-ti-tout]

*sigh...*