Carbon vs Midnight Club 3 Dub Edition 3 Remix

[Gtek-i]

gameplay...as simple as that...vote...I haven't played Carbon but I'm pretty sure that it is pretty good. Midnight 3 Remix is good too. Overall, I go for Carbon cause of the features but the cars on both are all pretty cool!!!

[hec16]

I'm almost finishing carbon and I love the moding the cars specially the muscle cars and I love making rims in the autosculp
________
HotLady

[The_Canuck]

Im sorry but midnightclub 3 is SH*T.

[Rockefella]

I vote for 'They Both Suck.'

[092326001]

NFS Carbon is a bit better in my opinion but Forza Motorsports is superior to both.
Can't wait for Forza Motorsports 2.

[Drift Illusion]

Racing games have yet to match the awesome power of Autosculpt. Carbon all the way!!

[clutch-monkey]

i voted for Forza 2.
yes, a game that's not even out yet is better than these two.

[F1_Master]

MC:3. It was actully hard, and you can use the supercars in a much better city layout.

Carbon is only great for the first 70% of completion. After that, all the best cars are only available online, so if you don't have Live!, you can't drive the CCX or LP640 unless you want to drive it riced out on just 1 course....

[Quiggs]

I vote for "Anything called Dub Edition and/or Rockefella sucks."

[ferrarifreak013]

NFS Carbon is a bit better in my opinion but Forza Motorsports is superior to both.
Can't wait for Forza Motorsports 2.

good call on that one i already have mine preordered(have had for about two months now) and i cant wait anylonger but they are totally diferent types of games ment for different people

[TVR IS KING]

As far as street racing modification games go...I dont think Carbon will live up to Midnight Club 3, even with Autosculpt. I havent actually played it, but considering NFS has been continuously outshined by everything, since it set the original standards with NFS U1...I voted MC.

[man 430gt]

i voted for Forza 2.
yes, a game that's not even out yet is better than these two.

Oh yes, this load of cap MNC 3 and carbon cack, dissappointing we have members will to promote this...Crap? No but seriously both games are not my type, way too childish..

[Vaigra]

I vote for Gran Turismo 1. Just shows the class of these games.

[ruim20]

I'll vote Lotus Chalenge! Fix That poll dammit!

[adrenaline]

Midnight Club. IMO, it's more fun to drive the cars. It's completely unrealistic, the driving dynamics are crazy. I haven't test driven carbon yet (it's not out in Australia yet), but if it's anything like Most wanted I'll be keeping my distance.